← Back to Journal ai-seo

Dave & Buster’s Doubles Down on Agencies, Hoping Ads Will Save Its Empty Arcades

🗓️ · ✍️ ElephantNY Editorial · 📍 NYC & Aegean Hospitality
Dave & Buster’s Doubles Down on Agencies, Hoping Ads Will Save Its Empty Arcades

Saturday afternoon in Times Square — a Dave & Buster’s location so desperate for foot traffic you can practically smell the flop sweat over the scent of stale fries. Instead of fixing the actual product (half-broken games, overpriced drinks, and the vibe of a corporate holiday party in hell), the company has decided to throw money at Gut for creative and Mediaplus for media buying. Because, sure, what Dave & Buster’s really needs is another campaign about ‘fun’ instead of, you know, actual fun.

Let’s call this what it is: classic agency roulette. Cycle through vendors, buy some award-bait creative, and pray some 27-year-old ‘strategy lead’ can TikTok your way past irrelevance. Gut’s work will be shiny and probably win a Cannes Lion, but unless they can turn a lukewarm mozzarella stick into a destination, it’s lipstick on a pig.

And Mediaplus? Great, now we can look forward to pre-roll ads reminding us that video arcades still exist, sandwiched between AI-generated insurance spots and the latest NFT grift. No media plan on earth fixes the fundamental problem: people don’t need another excuse to sit in a noisy, sticky mall restaurant. They need a reason to leave the house that isn’t nostalgia for 1999.

Here’s a radical thought for Dave & Buster’s C-suite this autumn: invest in your actual locations. Gut and Mediaplus can’t engineer FOMO out of thin air — not when your core product feels like a less-cool Chuck E. Cheese for salarymen. Stop outsourcing your survival to agencies, and start fixing the experience that made you famous in the first place. Or just keep writing checks and praying the next campaign brings in more than a handful of bored office parties. Your call.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which agencies did Dave & Buster’s hire?

Dave & Buster’s hired Gut as its creative agency and Mediaplus for media buying.

Why does the author criticize Dave & Buster’s agency hires?

The author argues that new agencies and advertising can’t fix the chain’s underlying product and in-store experience problems. He calls the move ‘agency roulette’ and says it outsources the company’s survival to vendors.

What problems does the author say Dave & Buster’s has?

The author cites half-broken games, overpriced drinks, and a corporate-holiday-party atmosphere. He also describes the venue as a noisy, sticky mall restaurant that lacks a compelling reason to visit beyond nostalgia.

What prompted the author to write about Dave & Buster’s?

The piece was prompted by a Saturday afternoon visit to the Times Square location, which the author describes as having little foot traffic.

What does the author recommend Dave & Buster’s do instead?

The author urges the C-suite to invest in its actual locations this autumn rather than rely on marketing campaigns. He says the company should fix the experience that made it famous instead of just writing checks to agencies.

Editorial Transparency. A first draft of this story was produced with AI-assisted writing tools, then reviewed for accuracy and tone by the named editor before publication. More on our process: Editorial Policy.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Weekly stories and what is opening this week.

Ready to Dominate AI Search Recommendations?

Run a free AI check on your restaurant or book a 20-minute call.

Launch AI Visibility Scanner →