Stop Pretending Communications Is Strategic: Time to Burn Down the PR Playbook

Let’s cut the nonsense: the so-called “communications revolution” is about as radical as a new LinkedIn filter. On this chilly September weekend, a parade of self-appointed comms gurus are still selling the same tired playbook they were hawking in conference rooms back when dial-up modems were a thing. Mark Bain—veteran, mentor, corporate board fixture—wants communicators to “supercharge impact.” I’ll translate: he wants the profession to finally matter. Here’s the ugly truth: most comms teams are still glorified email forwarders, paid to soften bad news and slap lipstick on quarterly turds.
Just walk into any Midtown agency this week. You’ll find fifteen “strategists” debating whether to use Slack or Teams while the CMO quietly outsources real influence to the analytics team. Why? Because the PR industry is addicted to process over outcomes, busywork over backbone. The press release industrial complex—still alive and well in 2026!—is a perfect example. How many of these templated nothings actually shift public perception? Zero. How many get written anyway? All of them, by people who’d rather play internal politics than pick up the phone to a hostile reporter.
The worst offenders? The LinkedIn PR influencers who still push “thought leadership” decks and “reputation management” webinars, as if AI-driven crisis cycles and TikTok mobs care about your talking points. If communications is actually more valued today, it’s only because the stakes are higher—one dumb slip and your CEO is trending for all the wrong reasons. But most comms pros are too busy perfecting jargon to actually shape the narrative.
The uncomfortable recommendation: fire half your comms department and replace them with people who can code, analyze sentiment at scale, and aren’t terrified of conflict. Stop hiring for “poise” and “polish.” Start hiring for intellectual violence and technical fluency. If your comms team can’t run a real-time media scan and counterpunch in under 15 minutes, they’re dead weight. Revolution isn’t a panel topic. It’s a blood sport. Start acting like it.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main argument of ‘Stop Pretending Communications Is Strategic’?
The author argues that most corporate communications teams are process-obsessed, non-strategic ’email forwarders’ and that the industry’s traditional playbook of press releases, thought leadership, and reputation webinars is obsolete.
How many comms staff does the author recommend firing?
The author recommends firing half of a company’s communications department. Those roles would be replaced by people who can code, analyze sentiment at scale, and handle conflict.
What skills does the author want in new communications hires?
The author says to stop hiring for ‘poise’ and ‘polish’ and instead hire for technical fluency and a willingness to engage in conflict. Ideal hires can code, analyze sentiment at scale, and aren’t afraid of confrontation.
What is the 15-minute benchmark for comms teams in the article?
The author says a comms team that cannot run a real-time media scan and counterpunch in under 15 minutes is ‘dead weight.’
Why does the author criticize press releases?
The author calls the continued existence of the ‘press release industrial complex’ in 2026 a prime example of process over outcomes, claiming none of these templated releases actually shift public perception. They add that people write them anyway rather than calling a hostile reporter.
Ready to Dominate AI Search Recommendations?
Run a free AI check on your restaurant or book a 20-minute call.
Launch AI Visibility Scanner →
Yorum Yap